I love Batman: Year One.


While I didn’t really Read Comics growing up, I did read a few specific comic books and graphic novels.  Among them: Frank Miller’s Batman: Year One.  This was (with the possible exception of the original Tim Burton film) my first direct exposure to Batman, and I loved it. 

Year One tells the story of the launching of Batman’s career, as it were—the transformation of a young, angry, obsessed Bruce Wayne from directionless seeker to directed, personified force.  It is, in parallel, a development of the character of future commissioner Jim Gordon, in the book a pushing-middle-age transplant to Gotham.  (The recent film Batman Begins is not based on, but does pay considerable homage to, this book.  Gary Oldman is, visually at least, a spitting image of Miller’s Gordon, and a few shots/moments, such as Gordon ascending the steps of a building while SWAT looks on, are clear references.) 

The writing is very good—this is the sort of book you can hand without embarassment to someone who doesn’t read comics—but the art is, as I see it, essential to the success of the book.

It doesn’t look like a superhero comic.

There’s a certain stylistic implausibility to superhero stories: these are people with catchy, cartoonish names who run around in tights.  They have superpowers and they have dating problems.  There’s a constant mix of world-shaking threats and interpersonal drama that doesn’t really make sense in the cold light of day.  Not that there’s anything wrong with that—they’re stories, and they’re operating in a tradition, an storytelling culture where these things are at least internally consistent.

But what Miller does in Year One is strip down as much of that as he can while still having an obsessed billionaire run around in a costume calling himself Batman.  The art is dirty and grim and unfantastic—Gotham isn’t a dystopia, it’s just a bad place to live, and the villains are corrupt politicians and crooked cops, not chortling fruitcakes with superweapons.  Batman himself is a fledgling vigilante, a lifeless, friendless, anti-social man who puts on a costume because, ultimately, he doesn’t know what else to do, because he can’t stand simply being himself.

And it’s all in dark lines, flat, broken faces, flickers of emotion in a heavy, pain-in-the-ass world.  No flashy stuff, no attention-getting flourishes, just stark, simple linework and wonderful muted colors that make you believe, if anything could, that there’s a good cop and a mad/sane costumed billionaire trying to make little things right in a city chock full of wrongness and badness.

Frank Miller’s other big Batman book, The Dark Knight Returns, covers the other bookend of the Batman saga—Bruce Wayne pushing sixty, retired and restless.  The art is still very Frank Miller, but the execution is more DC Comics, superheroes in classic form, than Year One.  It’s also very good, but where Year One has realist lines and an almost anti-comic feel, Dark Knight has larger-than-life characters in huge, dynamic superhero poses, and a whole cavalcade of men in tights.  Great art, but not the same sort: I don’t love it.  I don’t want to emulate it.

[Update!  Attentive reader layne points out that Year One was illustrated by David Mazzuchelli, with Miller writing, something I had half-forgotten and wholly failed to emphasize in the writeup.  It's Frank's Batman, but not his pen.]

There are no comments on this post

Leave a Reply

viagra risks erectile dysfunction viagra mixing cocaine and viagra viagra canada cheap viagra nz viagra price viagra drug interactions buy viagra montreal viagra generic pfizer viagra india ganeric viagra viagra shelf life buying viagra canada online overnight viagra viagra with alcohol cheap viagra 100mg cheap viagra viagra voucher nonprescription viagra australia viagra from canada cnn buy viagra australia canada free sample viagra buy viagra usa canada viagra mail viagra pills for sale buy generic viagra viagra toronto buy canada viagra viagra coupons and discounts generic viagra austrailia viagra junk email generic viagra uk generic viagra patent viagra austrialia viagra price comparison buy viagra online ireland order viagra canada viagra 100mg instructions viagra gel sale viagra price compare generic viagra discount viagra gold viagra for boys order viagra australia generic viagra india viagra without prescription australia viagra pro viagra jokes viagra grapefruit viagra online from canada viagra canada free sample viagra online nz viagra generic review viagra price pfizer viagra results viagra canada online viagra history buy viagra online viagra prices viagra overnight delivery usa canadian pharmacy viagra generic viagra photos order viagra paypal generic viagra jelly viagra and women generic viagra for sale australian online viagra buyimg viagra in australia online pharmacy canada viagra viagra warnings buy viagra online canada buy viagra canada australian viagra viagra quick tabs viagra australia online online viagra in australia buy viagra nz generic viagra effectiveness buy viagra pills viagra prices australia viagra coupon viagra professional cheap viagra real viagra viagra online in canada genaric viagra viagra headache cure toronto viagra buy viagra in canada get viagra in canada viagra price walgreens viagra overdose viagra jacket viagra use buy viagra fast canada pharmacy chewable viagra viagra triangle viagra sale cialis viagra canada viagra for sale generic viagra brands viagra dose viagra experiences pfizer viagra eservice viagra versus generic viagra generic viagra alternatives viagra price in india viagra professional canada generic viagra buy canada pharmacy viagra viagra in sacramento ca viagra for sale viagra nitric oxide cheap viagra canada generic viagra sample viagra women generic viagra kamagra generic viagra complaints viagra price comparison viagra price uk viagra espanol viagra teenney buy viagra shanghai viagra dose size canada medication viagra viagra quit working viagra onlnine viagra paypal payment canada order viagra now viagra gel online pharmacy online viagra generic viagra usa viagra sale guarenteed generic viagra viagra cheap canada viagra results photos brand viagra offers viagra empty stomach viagra gel tabs generic viagra work buy viagra australia generic viagra toronto ggeneric viagra for sale pfizer viagra sales viagra pfizer viagra professional australia viagra how much viagra tips viagra joint pain viagra price australia viagra sales canada buy viagra japan viagra usa viagra in uk genuine viagra in australia viagra price malaysia low cost viagra generic viagra professional buy viagra jelly generic viagra problems viagra nitroglycerin canada and generic viagra viagra by mail canada generic viagra ingredients viagra online netherlands generic viagra price viagra women effects next day shipping viagra viagra cheap prices generic viagra capsules canadian generic viagra order viagra online viagra dosing pfizer viagra packaging generic viagra image generic viagra canada buy viagra gel pfizer viagra online best viagra online toronto viagra sale canada viagra substitute real viagra paypal best price viagra australia viagra 100mg buy viagra perth generic viagra 50mg viagra and canada generic viagra cvs viagra quebec order viagra online buy viagra thailand viagra and alcohol canada generic in viagra viagra dependency viagra twitter viagra usa overnight shipping generic viagra canada viagra usage tips pfizer viagra liquid generic viagra price viagra recreational use viagra us pharmacy viagra recommended dosage viagra low cost viagra pills street value for viagra viagra from tijuana viagra canada sales viagra quick delivery redtube viagra pills viagra canada viagra blue vision herbal viagra in australia herbal viagra alternative australia viagra online buy viagra generic generic viagra from canada dsicount viagra online viagra canada viagra ring viagra trial pack canada generic viagra viagra canada australia viagra canada free viagra viagra meaning generic viagra us viagra in canada pfizer viagra buy viagra online canada viagra for sale uk bying viagra uk buy viagra melbourne brand viagra online sex shop viagra free viagra canada buy viagra brand online viagra viagra jelly viagra price cvs viagra half life generic viagra manufacturers viagra online 365 viagra yahoo viagra jamaica generic viagra walgreens viagra cost viagra gel uk indo viagral generic viagra fraud viagra gel sachets viagra nitrates buy viagra viagra 100mg effects generic viagra illegal viagra generic name where to buy viagra generic viagra information 100mg viagra buy viagra paypal viagra greate britain generic viagra viagra ingredients viagra buy online viagra interactions viagra aust shipping viagra to australia buy viagra online sydney generic viagra in canada brand name viagra canada viagra paypal checkout generic viagra cost viagra cost walmart viagra blood pressure pfizer viagra tablets generic viagra soft buy oral viagra online liquid viagra to buy viagra deals viagra cheap pfizer viagra online viagra quiz generic viagra 100mg sildenafil herbal viagra samples buy viagra professional buy viagra amsterdam super viagra uk generic viagra available viagra youtube viagra for sale online viagra (sildenafil) generic viagra canadian buy super viagra viagra sildenafil buy generic viagra reviews order viagra canada viagra coupons printable viagra insurance coverage buy viagra sydney viagra gel thailand generic viagra australia viagra trial viagra alternatives viagra samples viagra from canada legitimate viagra quotes sildenafil vs viagra viagra vision loss viagra in hong kong viagra patent expiration date viagra costs walmart viagra natural alternative viagra online viagra testimonials viagra jelly sachet reasons to use viagra buy viagra london generic viagra 100mg generic viagra gel walmartprices for viagra canada viagra cheap viagra uk viagra soft tabs buy viagra sildenafil viagra blindness pfizer viagra cheap viagra australia canada viagra buy buy wholesale viagra viagra oklahoma city purchase viagra from canada viagra order canada discount viagra pfizer viagra 100mg cheapest viagra prices canada viagra best price viagra otc aftermarket viagra viagra 100mg pfizer viagra uk viagra yahoo answers generic viagra buy viagra locally viagra price order viagra sample buy viagra pfizer viagra ketoconazole viagra canada samples pfizer viagra sample viagra market share canada ireland manufacturer viagra discount viagra canada generic toronto viagra australia in sale viagra viagra mailing list buy viagra from germany viagra commercial viagra super active australia viagra canada satisfaction guarantee viagra altitude sickness viagra 50mg pills viagra women use order viagra discrete viagra australia viagra price walmart viagra refractory period viagra online sell viagra alternatives india pfizer viagra review viagra side effects viagra in united states viagra price costco viagra junk mail viagra under tongue viagra quantity limits buy viagra uk australian viagra online generic viagra dangers viagra alcohol effects buy viagra cvs viagra dosage instructions buy viagra online viagra 100mg generic viagra mail order buy viagra philippines cheap viagra viagra from canada cost of viagra generic viagra when generic viagra soft tabs viagra over night viagra canada viagra generic viagra distributors viagra manufacturer viagra effects viagra soft tablets viagra benefits viagra super force viagra jet lag viagra online pharmacy drug similiar to viagra viagra products australia viagra pro online original viagra for sale viagra prescription canada viagra purchase canada pfizer viagra coupons order viagra discreetly viagra patent order viagra cheep viagra buy viagra montreal viagra tabs generic viagra paypal viagra maximum dose viagra professional generic non prescription viagra australia buy viagra pharmacy viagra express order viagra uk viagra facts buy viagra singapore generic viagra overnight viagra walgreens generic viagra 50mg viagra online toronto canada viagra super active generic viagra vs viagra trial sample free viagra sample pack alternatives to viagra viagra vancouver viagra loest prise viagra young adults viagra cheap generic viagra vs viagra viagra cost in canada viagra canada review 100mg viagra viagra reviews viagra gel caps buy viagra pakistan generic viagra viagra tolerance cheap generic viagra pills paypal viagra generic viagra mastercard cheap generic viagra 100mg viagra recreational order viagra from canada generic viagra online viagra au canada viagra 100mg tablets viagra online australia viagra in australia viagra headache viagra pills for sale purchasing viagra in canada viagra india canada generic viagra viagra canada deliver brand viagra cheap viagra australia information stories buy viagra spray viagra dosage canada generic viagra names generic viagra pictures viagra sales generic viagra viagra and dapoxetine viagra price thailand viagra canada cost coverage viagra price nz viagra professional scam buy strong viagra generic viagra cipla canada super viagra viagra on line generic viagra cheap genuine viagra australia viagra online sale canada viagra uk viagra professional review generic viagra joke viagra expiration date viagra 4 pack online pharmacy viagra generic viagra scam viagra 100mg reviews amazon viagra viagra 30 tablets viagra canada pharmacy viagra prices chip viagra viagra young men viagra generic canada viagra ireland viagra in usa viagra knock offs viagra information generic viagra safe generic viagra walmart buy viagra cheap shipping viagra to canada viagra 100mg dosage ordering viagra online buy viagra canada review viagra 50mg price viagra pro ingredients 200mg viagra viagra user reviews buy viagra legally pfizer viagra pills buy viagra malaysia viagra grapefruit interaction viagra canada free viagra price canada generic viagra discussion viagra from canada viagra mail order cheap viagra viagra soft pills revatio vs viagra buy viagra in canada generic viagra dosage viagra like drugs canada from generic viagra viagra and pregancy viagra canada prescription buy viagra using paypal buy viagra australia viagra for sell supreme suppliers viagra viagra coupons buy viagra toronto viagra in usa viagra at walmart buy viagra super force viagra effectiveness viagra walmart generic viagra viagra coupons viagra pro online canada viagra discount viagra order viagra overnight viagra teenney stones viagra message board viagra instructions viagra stories viagra canada online pharmacy pfizer viagra price pfizer viagra canada order viagra cheap viagra for sale australia viagra nasal congestion generic viagra paypal viagra pro reviews buy viagra in toronto generic viagra viagra single tabs caustion funny viagra buy viagra mastercard viagra 50mg canada canada viagra prescription buy viagra delhi viagra upset stomach buy viagra canada viagra online best viagra source generic viagra testimonials generic viagra sildenafil buy viagra tablets buy viagra from canada viagra dosage recommended viagra soft flavoured viagra usa viagra with dapoxetine overnight buy viagra dubai viagra no prescrition viagra young people viagra chemist prices australia viagra hearing loss canada viagra overnight prescription free viagra australia cheap viagra 50 mg viagra super force online viagra softtabs viagra professional online generic viagra safety viagra young man viagra by mail viagra windsor canada buy viagra pfizer viagra uk pfizer viagra price viagra generic equivalent generic viagra legal pfizer viagra 100mg canada online pharmacy viagra buy viagra online viagra prices viagra samples free viagra online viagra prices walmart does generic viagra work cost of viagra canada viagra douglas pharmaceuticals australia generic viagra buy viagra canada pharmacies generic viagra fake generic viagra real viagra directions viagra price increase viagra store in canada viagra youth generic viagra australia sildenafil generic viagra cheapest viagra viagra 100 tablets buy viagra bangkok viagra 50mg cost cheap viagra online viagra profesionals viagra soft tabs viagra last longer viagra online in usa viagra on line generic viagra from india viagra contraindications viagra rrp australia cost pfizer viagra instructions buy viagra india overnight generic viagra viagra medicare viagra in women generic viagra offers pfizer viagra patent viagra melbourne viagra 100mg cost viagra premature ejaculation viagra 100mg pills viagra australia information viagra buy viagra generic canada viagra 50mg tablets buy viagra sample walmart pharmacy viagra purchase generic viagra generic viagra online cheap viagra online canada buy viagra safely viagra free trial offer generic viagra 50 mg generic viagra risks viagra alternatives australia canada viagra paypal viagra 100mg price viagra for sale pfizer viagra cost viagra india buy viagra online buy viagra usa cheap viagra viagra by mail viagra american express canada viagra free samples pfizer viagra generic viagra pro scam viagra tablets viagra gum brand viagra canada canadian pharmacies selling viagra buy viagra manchester buy viagra ebay viagra rrp australia viagra and diabetes buy viagra europe viagra questions viagra japan order viagra online australia viagra available in toronto generic viagra pharmacy viagra super active buy viagra now viagra suppliers canada viagra for women viagra gel sildenafil viagra